| go to index of reviews | go to entry page | | go to other departments |


Lucy Komisar



Hare's "Skylight," a sharp look at young woman-older guy affair and (political) morality

" Skylight."
Written by David Hare; directed by Stephen Daldry.
John Golden Theatre, 252 W. 45th Street, between Broadway and 8th Avenue, New York City.
212-239-6200; http://www.skylightbwy.com/.
Opened April 2, 2015; closes June 21, 2015.
Reviewed by Lucy Komisar April 11, 2015.

Carey Mulligan as Kyra Hollis and Bill Nighy as Tom Sargeant. Photo by John Haynes.

Love, sex, age and class. Key elements in David Hare's 1995 play about a rich guy who had an affair with an employee a few years ago and would like to start it up again.

He runs restaurants. She was a lawyer's daughter (ie. privileged) who wandered into his eatery on Kings Road and got a job. And a promotion. And a lover. She left six years later when his wife discovered the affair.

First issue is that with Hare, a writer of the left, the story should be about political attitudes. The script calls for Kyra to be just past 30 and Tom to be near 50. Carey Mulligan who plays Kyra is 29. But Bill Nighy is a craggy-faced 65. Nighy is a terrific actor, but this is bad casting. The script's age difference is large enough, but in this case she could be his daughter.

Stephen Daldry's direction is at once smooth, sharp and subtle, but he is directing another play, which has to do with a poor young women and a rich old man. It confuses the issue.

Matthew Beard as Edward Sergeant. Photo by John Haynes.

We are in Kyra's apartment in a working class part of northwest London. The kitchen has a plain wood table, two chairs and a water heater. Through translucent back walls we see the façade of the council flats building across the courtyard.

She doesn't have money. She teaches poor kids – not what the society values. She wears pants and a baggy sweater. Her flat is cold. Mulligan is cool, realistic.

Tom's son Edward (Matthew Beard) arrives unannounced. Beard is terrific as an edgy jittery 18 year old. He's dealing with death of his mother and an unresponsive father.

Bill Nighy as Tom Sergeant and Carey Mulligan as Kyra Hollis. Photo by John Haynes.



Later Tom appears, with a bottle of whiskey. He has longish gray hair. He is rich and self-involved. He has already "discounted" his wife's death. Discounted: a business term. He pointedly won’t take off his coat, because it's too cold. He is insufferable.

It's three years after the affair. He accuses Kyra of having a bad attitude to business. In some ways, this is a funny satire.

He says, "Then – oh Christ! – there's this fatal moment. Expansion!"
Kyra: "Sure."
Tom: "And then you borrow. And then you're no longer in business, you're no longer in what I'd call business, because it's nothing to do with the customer. It's you and the bank. And it's war! They always have new ways of punishing initiative."

Nighy's facial expressions are as good as dialogue, reporting his fury and anguish. (Sometimes it seem like overacting.) During all of this, Kyra is (really) cooking Bolognese sauce for pasta. Steam comes from the pot.

About the morality of businessmen, we discover that Tom left his wife as she lay dying. Wouldn't Kyra like to join him in his house on a Caribbean island?

Bill Nighy as Tom Sergeant and Carey Mulligan as Kyra Hollis. Photo by John Haynes.

This play is about values; theirs are now different. She has left the warm bubble of money. Challenged by dealing with poor kids from other countries, she talks about seeing England as it really is. She says "Most people live differently. You have no right to look down."

He snobbishly disdains her for teaching people at "the bottom of the heap." He says, "You could be teaching at any university." He accuses her of female stubbornness.

She responds furiously: "I'm tired of these sophistries. I'm tired of these right-wing fuckers. They wouldn't lift a finger themselves. They work contentedly in offices and banks. Yet now they sit pontificating in parliament, in papers, impugning our motives, questioning our judgements. And why? Because they themselves need to feel better by putting down everyone whose work is so much harder than theirs."

Carey Mulligan as Kyra. Photo by John Haynes.

She tells him, "Anyone can play. But there's only one rule. You can't play for nothing. You have to buy some chips to sit at the table. And if you won't pay with your own time … with your own effort … then I’m sorry. Fuck off!"

He accuses her of not giving herself in love. That she loves the people, because she doesn't have to go home with them.

Why do men always think it's all about them?

Kyra: "I mean, apart from anything, there is the arrogance, the unbelievable arrogance of this middle-aged man to imagine that other people's behavior – his ex's behavior – is always in some direct reaction to him."

So, the guys who were turned on by an older man-young women meme will get another lesson. And David Hare fans will get another example of why his plays always deliver a deft political message.


Visit Lucy Komisar's website http://thekomisarscoop.com/


| home | reviews | cue-to-cue | discounts | welcome |
| museums | NYTW mail | recordings | coupons | publications | classified |